REHMON FAILS, Administrator, ET AL., Claimant, v. STATE OF ILLINOIS, Respondent.
Case summary
Claimant sought damages for the wrongful death of Mary Louise Fails due to scald burns suffered while a patient at Manteno State Hospital. The court awarded $5,000 based on a joint stipulation of the parties.
AI-generated summary from the opinion text — may contain errors. The opinion text and PDF above are the official record.
Headnotes
- DAMAGES-stippuhtion. Where Claimant and Respondent stipulate to facts and damages an award will be entered accordingly. Claimant received negligent care at state hospital resulting in burns to body and ultimately death.
This cause coming on to be heard on the Joint
Stipulation of the parties hereto, and the Court being
fully advised in the premises; [*479]
This Court finds that this claim is for the damages sustained as a result of the death of Mary Louise Fails while a patient at the Illinois Department of Mental Health facilities at Manteno, Illinois.
On May 19, 1973, she resided at Manteno State Hospital. At approximately 1O:OO a.m., Manteno aides put Mary in a bathtub, turned on the water, and left her in the tub for approximately 30 minutes. During the bath Mary complained that the water was too hot. Several aides placed their hands in the water and stated that it was lukewarm. Mary required assistance in getting out of the tub. As she was being lifted from the tub her skin began to peel off the left knee and buttocks.
Dr. Georgis, a staff physician, was called immediately. Mary was taken to Bowen Hospital where Dr. Olivares’ examination showed: “Circulatory collapse. Extensive second degree burns about 20 to 30 percent .”
Mary was transferred to Chicago Read Hospital where she died on May 31, 1973, due to complications following the injury. The injury was diagnosed as scald burns. No autopsy was performed.
An extensive investigation was made at the Manten0 facility to determine the cause of Mary’s injuries. The investigation ruled out radiator, water and sun burns.
Several alternative theories were proposed by William Kunz, Administrative Assistant at Manteno State Hospital; he concludes his report by stating, “I cannot find any single alternative hypothesis which, taken by itself, seems appreciably more likely than the scald theory.”
A coroner’s inquest was held on September 20, 1973, at 11:30 a.m., which included the cause of death [*480] from the pathological report and protocol signed by Dr. Tae Lyong An, the Coronor’s pathologist:
In my opinion, the said Mary Louise Fails’ death was due to septic shock incidental to scale bums.
The verdict of the Coronor’s jury was:
We, the jury, do not know how, when or where the deceased received said injuries; therefore, our verdict is undetermined as to whether this is an accident or otherwise.
At the time of Mary’s death, the statutory maximum recovery against the State was $25,000.00.
The Attorney General’s office filed a counterclaim against the Estate in the amount of $17,312.80 for the hospital care and treatment of Mary Louise Fails from June 20,1970, through May 31, 1973.
The decedent is survived by a minor child, Cathy
Jean Fails. I
The Department of Mental Health, represented by Special Assistant Attorney General Ronald W. Olson, decided that the claim should be adjusted if possible, and the Department concurred.
Pursuant to the Department’s request for an adjustment, a stipulation was prepared and sent to the Court, whereby it appears that all matters in controversy between Claimant and the State of Illinois have been adjusted to the mutual satisfaction of the parties and their attorneys.
Claimant is hereby awarded the sum of Five Thousand Dollars ($5,000).