DOMINIC TOSI, ADMINISTRATOR OF ESTATE OF ROSE TOSI, DECEASED v. STATE OF ILLINOIS.
Case summary
Claimant sought damages for the death of his minor daughter, an inmate at the Illinois School for the Deaf, who died after a surgical operation performed without parental consent. The court found no legal liability but recommended a legislative appropriation of $1,500 as an act of social justice.
AI-generated summary from the opinion text — may contain errors. The opinion text and PDF above are the official record.
Headnotes
- NON-LIABILITY OF STATE-State not liable for death of an inmate of its SOCIAL JUSTICE AND EQUITY-recommendation. As an act of social
DOMINIC TOSI, ADMINISTRATOR OF ESTATE OF ROSE TOSI, DECEASED v.
STATE OF ILLINOIS.
Opinion filed April 26, 1931.
NON-LIABILITY OF STATE-State not liable for death of an inmate of its institution. Claimant's intestate, a minor, an inmate in the Illinois School for the Deaf, at Jacksonville, died from the effects of a necessary surgical operation performed under the direction of the authorities of the institution.
Held, that the State is not liable.
SOCIAL JUSTICE AND EQUITY-recommendation. As an act of social justice and equity the Court recommends to the Legislature an appropriation to claimant.
Edward J. Brundage, Attorney General, for State.
It appears from the evidence that Rose Tosi, daughter of Dominic Tosi, a resident of Bureau County, Illinois, was afflicted with deafness, and that her said father placed her in charge of the Illinois School for the Deaf, located at Jacksonville, Illinois, for the purpose of being educated and taken care of by the said institution. That the said child was an inmate of said institution up and until October 30, 1920. It further appears from the evidence that the condition of the health of said child was such that a surgical operation was extremely dangerous. That an operation was performed upon the child under the direction of the immediate authorities of said institution, and that such operation was performed without the consent of the father of said child, the said child being then and there a minor. And it is charged by the said claimant that as a result of said operation and said Rose Tosi died on the 30th day of October, 1920. It further appears from the evidence that the claimant was put to considerable expense on account of the funeral and other incidentals.
The Court finds that there is no legal liability resting on the State of Illinois under this claim; however, as a matter of equity and social justice this Court recommends an appropriation by the Legislature in the sum of fifteen hundred dollars ($1,500). [*191]